Contract Act, Section 133: Discharge of Surety by Variance in the Terms of the Contract
Section 133 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 governs the discharge of a surety when the terms of the contract between the principal debtor and creditor are altered without the surety’s consent.
The section provides that any unauthorized variance in the original contract discharges the surety from liability for subsequent transactions affected by such alteration, protecting him from changed obligations.
1. Purpose of Section 133
The primary objective of Section 133 is to protect the surety from being held liable under a contract whose terms have been changed without his approval.
The provision ensures that the surety remains liable only for the contract that he originally agreed to guarantee and not for a modified agreement that may expose him to additional or different risks.
2. Applicability of Section 133
Section 133 applies where there is a valid contract of guarantee between the creditor, the principal debtor, and the surety, and the creditor and principal debtor subsequently alter the terms of their contract.
The provision becomes operative only when such alteration is made without obtaining the consent of the surety.
3. Meaning of Variance
The term variance refers to any alteration, modification, amendment, or change made in the original terms and conditions of a contract.
Such changes may relate to payment, time, obligations, method of performance, scope of work, or any other condition affecting the rights and liabilities of the parties.
4. Consent of the Surety Is Essential
A fundamental requirement under Section 133 is the consent of the surety, as any alteration must be accepted to remain binding.
Where the surety consents to the alteration, the guarantee continues under modified terms, but without consent, the surety receives protection under Section 133.
5. Alteration Between Creditor and Principal Debtor
The variance contemplated by Section 133 must arise from an agreement between the creditor and the principal debtor without the surety’s consent.
Since the surety is bound by the original agreement, any unauthorized alteration cannot affect the surety’s liability unless he expressly agrees to it.
6. Discharge of the Surety
Where the statutory conditions of Section 133 are satisfied, the surety is discharged from liability by operation of law, as an unauthorized alteration of contractual terms without consent is sufficient to attract protection.
7. Effect Limited to Future Transactions
Section 133 provides that the surety is discharged only for transactions occurring after the unauthorized variance, while liabilities arising before the alteration remain unaffected and continue to bind the surety.
8. Protection Against Increased Risk
Section 133 protects the surety from unforeseen risks by preventing the creditor from altering the terms of the contract in a manner that increases the surety's liability or changes the original obligation without the surety's consent.
9. Principle of Fairness
The provision embodies the equitable principle that no person should be bound by contractual obligations that have been materially altered without his agreement.
Since the surety voluntarily accepted responsibility for a particular contract, fairness requires that he should not be held liable under a substantially different contract created without his participation.
Get expert support for GST, Company Registration, Trademark, Taxation and Compliance Services.
Get Free Consultation© 2020 CREDENCE CORPORATE SOLUTIONS PVT. LTD. | Website by Wits Digtal Pvt. Ltd.
Leave a Comment