Contract Act, Section 135: Discharge of Surety When the Creditor Compounds With, Gives Time to, or Agrees Not to Sue the Principal Debtor
Section 135 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 governs the discharge of a surety where the creditor enters into certain arrangements with the principal debtor without the surety’s consent.
The section provides that agreements involving composition, extension of time, or refusal to sue the principal debtor discharge the surety unless such arrangements are approved by him.
1. Purpose of Section 135
The primary objective of Section 135 is to protect the surety from being adversely affected by agreements entered into between the creditor and the principal debtor without the surety's consent.
The provision ensures that the surety remains liable only for the contractual arrangement originally undertaken and is not bound by subsequent agreements that may alter the creditor's rights against the principal debtor.
2. Applicability of Section 135
Section 135 applies where there is a valid contract of guarantee involving a creditor, a principal debtor, and a surety, and the creditor subsequently enters into a separate agreement with the principal debtor.
The provision becomes operative where such agreement consists of a composition, an extension of time, or a promise not to sue the principal debtor, and the surety has not consented to the arrangement.
3. Nature of the Surety's Liability
A surety undertakes a secondary obligation for the principal debtor's default, and any alteration of the creditor's rights against the principal debtor without the surety's consent may substantially affect the surety's position.
4. Composition With the Principal Debtor
One situation covered by Section 135 is where the creditor enters into a composition with the principal debtor, under which the debt is settled on mutually agreed terms.
Such a composition may discharge the surety because acceptance of a reduced amount or altered terms changes the original obligation without the surety’s consent.
5. Giving Time to the Principal Debtor
The section applies where the creditor agrees to give additional time to the principal debtor for payment or performance without the surety’s consent.
By extending the time without approval, the creditor alters the original arrangement, and the law protects the surety by providing discharge from liability.
6. Agreement Not to Sue the Principal Debtor
Another circumstance covered by Section 135 is where the creditor agrees not to institute legal proceedings against the principal debtor, thereby restricting enforcement of the obligation.
Such an agreement may affect the surety’s rights by delaying recovery, and the surety is discharged unless he has consented to the arrangement.
7. Consent of the Surety
Section 135 provides that the surety is discharged only when a composition, extension of time, or agreement not to sue the principal debtor is made without the surety's consent, while consent keeps the guarantee enforceable.
8. Protection of the Surety's Rights
Section 135 protects the surety's right of recovery against the principal debtor by ensuring that the creditor does not independently alter the debtor's liability through arrangements that may prejudice the surety.
9. Principle of Fairness
Section 135 embodies the equitable principle that one party should not, without another's consent, alter contractual arrangements in a manner that increases or changes the latter's liability.
Since the surety voluntarily accepted responsibility based upon the original contract, fairness requires that he should not be bound by subsequent agreements made without his approval.
Get expert support for GST, Company Registration, Trademark, Taxation and Compliance Services.
Get Free Consultation© 2020 CREDENCE CORPORATE SOLUTIONS PVT. LTD. | Website by Wits Digtal Pvt. Ltd.
Leave a Comment